Correct
Not quite — the correct answer is highlighted
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Answer: (C) Neither I nor II follows
Explanation
From Statement I, all papers are files. This means the set of papers is entirely contained within the set of files.
From Statement II, some files are pens. This means there is an intersection between the set of files and the set of pens.
This intersection of files and pens may or may not overlap with the set of papers. Therefore, two possibilities arise:
Possibility 1: The pens that are files do not overlap with the papers. In this case, no paper is a pen, making Conclusion I true but Conclusion II false.
Possibility 2: The pens that are files overlap with the papers. In this case, some papers are pens, making Conclusion II true but Conclusion I false.
Because neither conclusion is definitely true in all possible scenarios, neither Conclusion I nor Conclusion II follows individually.